It Was the Right Decision, on That Day, at That Time

I’ve been thinking lately about the decisions we make, particularly the financial ones, and how easy it is to look back and wonder whether we made the right choice.

Of course, hindsight has an unfair advantage. We know things today that we couldn’t possibly have known yesterday.

Let me tell you a little story.

In 2023, interest rates were climbing, inflation was taking a bite out of household budgets, and every Bank of Canada announcement seemed to bring another round of anxiety.

For homeowners with adjustable-rate mortgages, those were some uncomfortable months. Payments were increasing, nobody knew when the increases would end, and there was plenty of speculation about how much worse things might become.

During that period, one homeowner decided to make a change.

They transferred their mortgage to another lender, paid a penalty, locked into a fixed interest rate and increased their payments with the intention of paying off their home as quickly as possible.

A fairly straightforward decision, except for one small detail.

That homeowner had always been a strong believer in adjustable-rate mortgages.

So what changed?

Well, 2023 was an interesting year.

There was a lot of fear circulating. Fear about interest rates, the cost of living, housing affordability and whether people would have enough money to manage everything.

And when you spend enough time surrounded by those conversations, some of that uncertainty can begin to influence your own thinking.

Locking into a fixed rate offered certainty. The payments were predictable, there was a plan to eliminate the mortgage faster, and one financial worry could be crossed off the list.

At the time, that felt like a pretty good decision.

And for a while, everything went according to plan.

The mortgage balance was coming down quickly. Interest was being saved. There was satisfaction in watching the debt disappear.

But there was another side to the equation.

The homeowner was self-employed, and making those larger mortgage payments meant drawing more income from the business. More income meant more personal income tax.

Suddenly, paying off the mortgage faster wasn’t quite as straightforward as watching the balance decline.

The mortgage was shrinking, but at what cost to the bigger financial picture?

And was eliminating the mortgage as quickly as possible even the priority anymore?

Fast-forward to 2026.

Interest rates have changed, life has moved forward, and retirement is a little closer.

Recently, that same homeowner made another mortgage change.

The mortgage was restructured, the required payments were reduced, and the homeowner returned to an adjustable-rate mortgage.

The new arrangement created more flexibility, reduced the need to draw additional taxable income from the business and allowed for a different approach to managing money in the years ahead.

And here’s the part I haven’t told you.

That homeowner was me.

Yes, after more than 18 years of helping people make mortgage decisions, I found myself caught up in the same uncertainty that so many of my clients were experiencing.

I spend my days listening to people’s concerns about money. Whether they’ll have enough, whether their payments will increase, whether they’re making the right decisions for their families.

And somewhere along the way, I had taken on some of that scarcity thinking myself.

The funny thing is, my belief in adjustable-rate mortgages never changed. I’ve always appreciated the flexibility they offer, and I understand that interest rates move in both directions over time.

Yet, in 2023, I allowed the fear surrounding me to influence a decision that might have looked different had I stepped away from all the noise.

A mortgage broker getting caught up in mortgage anxiety. There’s a little irony in that.

But I’m human, too.

I have financial obligations, retirement plans, a business to manage and decisions to make about how I want the next chapter of my life to look.

Today, I’m back in an adjustable-rate mortgage. My payments are lower, my cash flow is more flexible, and I have more control over how much income I draw from my business.

I can continue making additional mortgage payments when they make financial sense, without committing myself to higher payments every month.

And I am quite content with that decision.

Would I make the same decision I made in 2023 today? Probably not.

Do I regret making it? No.

At the time, I was responding to a set of circumstances that felt important. Today, I have different priorities and a clearer understanding of what I want my money to accomplish.

I share my story because financial decisions aren’t always as tidy as we’d like them to be. Even with experience, knowledge and a good understanding of the numbers, emotions can find their way into the conversation.

Sometimes we make decisions because we’re worried. Sometimes because we’re excited. Sometimes because we’re simply tired of thinking about money.

And sometimes, a few years later, we look at the same situation and see something entirely different.

That’s perfectly human.

One of the things I’ve always valued about my work is being able to have open conversations about money without judgment. Not every financial decision works out exactly as planned, and not every plan needs to remain unchanged forever.

I certainly don’t have every answer for my own financial future, any more than I have every answer for yours.

But I do know the value of revisiting a decision, looking at the numbers again and asking whether the plan continues to make sense.

For me, 2023 was about certainty and paying off my mortgage.

In 2026, it’s about flexibility, managing taxes and preparing for the next chapter.

Different years. Different priorities. Different decisions.

And I’m perfectly fine with that.

Share this article on  your favourite platform